Maps of some classic dungeons, 2: karst cave systems
For just about as long as there have been cave dungeons, there have been people complaining that everyone does them wrong – that caves pose their own unique natural hazards and challenges, and that they’re way more interesting than 10′ corridors.
…and now I’m going to join them. Here I’m going to talk about (mostly) natural caverns. Mines and carved architecture deserve their own posts (and may get them, eventually).
One publication that doesn’t get it all wrong is Patrick and Scrap’s Veins of the Earth, which should get you back into caving after you were turned off it by the Dungeoneer’s Survival Guide all those years ago.
Already know all about this? Here, have some maps. Note how the mapper has to deal with bits of cave crossing and recrossing at different heights.
Still want more help?
In brief, the cool things I know about caves are:
1. they’re naturally totally dark BUT can have really, really long sight lines, so one sniper with infravision should be able to hold a whole underground river complex.
Except;
2. they tend to be really complex, ruffled, full of stalactites and overhangs and slippery bits and uneven floor, so you can probably hide a battalion in one and advance in little scurries and jumps.
So your lone sniper had better have a back door out, because a determined assault will always get them.
Except;
3. they’re full of surprise hidey-holes, some of which are only accessible by climbing up sheer cliffs or going underwater.
Oh yeah, right: many, many caves have interesting water features, like rivers and flash flooding, and constant drip-drip-dripping from aquifers closer to the surface, which in theory you might think you could trace to the surface, but they’re completely treacherous, because the water takes weird snaky paths to get to you, which might actually delay it by a few centuries on the way down.
(oh yeah and: cave diving is about as dangerous as skydiving while firefighting in a phone box.)
So water (or other fluid) keeps the air pockets of cave chambers separate, so those chambers can be filled with choking smoke or depleted of oxygen or contain pockets of poison gas.
And you think you’ve got to the deepest point but then;
4. they’re prone to suddenly opening out into giant cathedral chambers where a whole city can hide and you wonder why the soaring ceiling hasn’t opened up to the sky in a sinkhole yet.
And you also wonder how all the city-builders found this subterranean flask-hole, because you wouldn’t have stumbled across it (and nearly died getting in) if you hadn’t been pursued by armies of ninja goblins (or in my case been taken in by a tourist guide).
All this is because most big caves happen in karst country – where the local rock is a mix of limestone and something harder, but then water erosion strips the limestone out, leaving behind wild bubble and flask caverns, connected by narrow, twisty passages.
Natural karst tends to happen in limestone but it could occur anywhere you have mixed domains of hard and soft material – take the alternating layers of cooled lava and volcanic ash in Cappadocia, for example, where little chips remaining from a thin layer of basalt protect the soft tufa underneath them from being washed away in the rain:
(The great thing about ash is that you can carve it easily, so now you have rabbit warrens scooped out in your cave country. The bad thing about it is, once you’ve carved it, water can get in and then freeze in winter, forcing cracks and collapses. Which, for spontaneous opening of ancient dungeons, is kind of promising.)
…or what about post-apocalyptic deserts, where diggable sand and branching qanats lurk under the blasted, glassy surface?
Here are some things everyone should be doing with caves:
– underwater rivers mean underwater boats, which you row or punt. Being in a boat means being vulnerable to missile fire.
If they’re kayaks, you can totally roll them over and keep going through totally submerged passages, rolling back up where the ceiling allows.
(There’s a Sindbad story about this, where he comes up miles away from where he went into the cave, having followed an aquifer. It’s a one-way journey: the current is way too strong and the underwater passages too long to even think about trying to swim back.)
– narrow squeezes and swimming mean taking off your armor. All the best caves have rivers, every big cave has had cave-ins. I have been through a gap in the ATM cave in Belize where the only way to pass was to squeeze your neck through the narrow point between two fallen rocks, and to rotate your torso as you did so. I remember thinking “I don’t think there’s any way to get a breastplate in here.” And on the other side, the cave carried on for 5 miles, including a couple of caverns full of sacrifices of clay pots and a few bodies. So somebody managed to drag stuff in there.
– climbing after the swimming means soft or no shoes, to feel your way along narrow ledges. Even if you want to stick to the “floor” of a karst cave, you’ll probably do a lot of climbing. Floors tend to be littered with giant boulders from old cave-ins, or covered in shallow pools of chalky water that could be hiding anything, and cavern chambers are fairly often inconveniently placed at the top of exhaustingly long, ridiculously steep, glass-slippery stone slides with water running down them.
Here’s where you deal with the whole “how much equipment do I have?” question. The answer is: as much as you can swim and climb up slippery cliffs in. Whenever you’re in water, remember that the floor could disappear at any moment (karst bubble chambers, right? Also loose rocks wind up in the rivers, so footing is unreliable) so you’d better be buoyant.
The more detailed answer is: sure, by all means bring a load of equipment with you, in waterproof backpacks that float, with loads of rope and torches, and have the whole team relay that luggage to safe points and set up camps after every serious squeeze. Map and hammer in guide ropes and do all the professional taming of the underworld you can. But also remember, you may be under fire, and big cave systems can follow rivers for 30 miles or more underground, so torch longevity is a real issue. You probably want to be thinking about extending your overall exploration by like a mile a day, then retreating to camp, and maintaining constant supply lines to the surface. 20 people should be enough if you don’t meet serious resistance. Actually, now I’m excited about running a game of slow exploration and fast retreats: first you spend a load of time really understanding and preparing the ground, then you get chased back over it at breakneck speed, using routes you yourself built: the players are apprentices in an alien environment but masters of their own constructions.
– caves can be full of environmental treasure. Delicate spindly stalactites are beautiful, take millions of years to form, and are made out of minerals carried by water (or other solvents) from the inaccessible rock all around, so they tend to store up stuff gathered from the surroundings. Like for example magical essence from the demon killed centuries ago, or traces of rare isotopes from before The Fall.
Big stalactites are also great cover. And if you have no respect for strange aeons, you can saw through them to look at deep time and figure out the valley you’re in is a ticking time bomb of volcanic activity or something.
And unrestricted time + slow drying out can lead to some insane crystal formations:
(note: crystals tend to be strikingly pretty, valuable, and sacred. Their regular structures mean they also tend to resonate when struck. ……..rock music)
As for life, you don’t need me to tell you about exciting subterranean fungus colonies or slime molds or blind fish or bats, but what about olms and 200-year-old salamanders – creatures that time forgot? Because….
– caves are time capsules. Stuff in them tends lie out of the sight of man for centuries. Sacred texts, richly-appointed burials, sacrifices, statues, murals, dragon eggs. During those centuries, treasures are liable to get incorporated into the floor, as the cave floods and drains periodically, bringing minerals that crystallize as the waters subside. You may need a pick-axe. And regular deghosting.
– caves are mostly too complex, too stressful, and too secretive to be mapped on any convenient time scale.
“But Richard,” you whine, “my players want to map! On squared paper. That’s why we mostly do dungeons with 60′ corridors.”
Just don’t. Stay with me here – use different language. It’s not true to the experience of caving to say “the chamber is 60′ by 40′ with a 20′ ceiling, exits to the north, south and northeast.” NO. The cave is actually a completely mysterious space, wider than you could throw a shoe, full of interrupting, scalloped columns and silty pools, with a ceiling that’s mostly dark but has some glistening patches in it. You can see the river runs forward (no compass) and there’s a branching passage off to the right, but getting up into it means finding a path up 12′ or so of smooth rock surface, or trying to climb up a shallow but sharp-looking rock ridge, right round the edge of the cavern. Dark patches on the other side of the river might be entrances to other passages or just shadows cast by fallen rocks. You wanna trace your way back out of here? Bring a long ball of string with you.
Treat the cave as a point crawl or circuit diagram, with chambers connected by lines, and do what explorers did before the last few decades – just give the chambers evocative names, so the players tell them apart by reputation – Dead Drop, the Chimney, the Cathedral. Play on associative memory – a raised space in the middle of the Cathedral is obviously the Altar.
In short, go climb around some caves. There’s really no substitute for personal experience here (a two-edged sword, because if you do go caving, forever afterwards you’ll be saying yeah, words can’t really do it justice…). If you possibly can, it’s totally worth visiting even one big cave complex.
Sac Actun near the Mayan city of Tulun in south Mexico is completely flooded nowadays, but the maps are still worth your time, whether you want to fill it with Deep Ones/Yuan Ti or drain it and use it as a “straightforward” dungeon.
…yes, it actually is that blue.
Actun Tunichil Muknal cave in Belize provided many of the photos in this post. The entrances, one above the other with a colony of bats, are waiting to be used for an Indiana Jones location shot:
Gouffre de Paridac, which I’ve already mentioned, is in the south of France. And if you’ve been putting off going to the south of France for any reason other than lack of money, I just have to ask why?:
Closer to home for USians, obviously you know about Carlsbad Caverns in New Mexico. I hear Missouri also has a wealth of caves to explore. And I learned about NY’s Howe Caverns while writing this post. In Britain, I hear Yorkshire and the Peak District have good caves. I’m more familiar with the Cheddar Showcaves and Wookey Hole, which are worth a look, even if they’re pretty small potatoes (and really touristy. Like, cheesy not just because of the cheddar) compared with France’s riches:
…and never again treat a cave like a wobbly-walled corner of the dungeon.
Leave a comment Cancel reply
Recent Posts
- Singing in the Wilderness: reconstructing Dune pt.3
- Machines As The Measure Of Men: reconstructing Dune pt. 2
- Wind, Sand and Stars: reconstructing Dune pt. 1
- Coda: when to set the Arthurian Nights
- Bèton Breton
- Pre-Raphaelite Arthur part 2
- Pre-Raphaelite Arthur, part 1: Arabian Nights, Authenticity and the Arche
- Sedulous Icosahedron
- Good things about Phoenix Point – the world-building
- Architectural history for gamers 2b: mountains and misdirection
- Architectural history for gamers 2a: the holy mountain
- Architectural History for Gamers 2: telling stories with spaces
- How to have fun playing Phoenix Point
- Architectural History for Gamers, 1a: medieval and early modern forts
- Architectural History for Gamers, 1: why build city walls?
- XCOM in the mirror – Phoenix Point
- Learning from XCOM, 5: the bit that would be better as a TTRPG
- Maps of classic dungeons 4: the rats in the walls of the Opera Garnier
- an addendum to a really old post on Cha-based magic
- Learning from XCOM, 4: look how far we’ve come
- Epic inconveniences
- Learning from XCOM, 3: classes, advancement, and special moves
- Learning from XCOM, 2: a philosophy of cheating and balancing
- Learning from XCOM, 1: the rules that matter
- Art and Bitterness
- Learning from James Bond 4: Conclusions
- Learning from James Bond 3: Post-Soviet Chaos and the Age of Rage
- Learning from James Bond 2: 70s, 80s, the War on Drugs
- Learning from James Bond, 1: the 60s
- thoughts toward a flat earth campaign
Archives
- March 2024
- October 2023
- May 2023
- April 2023
- March 2023
- February 2023
- December 2022
- October 2022
- July 2022
- June 2022
- February 2022
- July 2021
- June 2021
- May 2021
- March 2021
- February 2021
- January 2021
- November 2020
- July 2020
- March 2020
- February 2020
- January 2020
- December 2019
- November 2019
- January 2019
- December 2018
- November 2018
- October 2018
- September 2018
- August 2018
- July 2018
- June 2018
- May 2018
- April 2018
- March 2018
- February 2018
- January 2018
- December 2017
- November 2017
- October 2017
- September 2017
- August 2017
- July 2017
- June 2017
- May 2017
- April 2017
- March 2017
- February 2017
- January 2017
- December 2016
- November 2016
- October 2016
- September 2016
- August 2016
- July 2016
- June 2016
- May 2016
- April 2016
- March 2016
- February 2016
- January 2016
- December 2015
- November 2015
- October 2015
- September 2015
- July 2015
- January 2015
- August 2014
- July 2014
- June 2014
- April 2014
- March 2014
- February 2014
- December 2013
- November 2013
- October 2013
- September 2013
- July 2013
- June 2013
- May 2013
- April 2013
- March 2013
- February 2013
- January 2013
- December 2012
- November 2012
- October 2012
- September 2012
- August 2012
- July 2012
- June 2012
- May 2012
- April 2012
- March 2012
- February 2012
- January 2012
- December 2011
- November 2011
- October 2011
- September 2011
- August 2011
- July 2011
- June 2011
- May 2011
- April 2011
- March 2011
- February 2011
- January 2011
- November 2010
- October 2010
- September 2010
- July 2010
- June 2010
- May 2010
- April 2010
- March 2010
Scrap Princess
- BEAST PEOPLE NAMES FOR BEAST PEOPLE
- Six Secret Books
- NooFutura available for purchase
- Leucrotta
- Weapon Breakage In Darksun
- Kickstarter Cognition Snare, 8th part of the Hexahedron of the Monks of Flame
- 6th Part Of Kick Starter Cognition Snare, The Hexahedron of the Flame Monks
- Kickstarter Cognition Snare: Hexahedron of the Monks of Flame : The Fouth Part
- Kickstarter Cognition Snare: Hexahedron of the Monks of Flame : The Second Part
- Demon Bone Sarcophagus Kickstarter Is Awrithe!
Reading Appendix N
- Two of my favorite practical mechanics in Delta Green
- A wild hair
- Longest campaigns I’ve played from 2008-2022, and other data neepery
- Going full-depth: collecting complete game lines
- My 2024 RPG collecting goal: All of Ars Magica 5th Edition
- DCC dice, inking, and pencils
- Sailing out of the painting doldrums with Blood Bowl
- New year, new look
- My Black Furnace #dungeon23 project is done!
- Godsbarrow apocalypse narrowly averted
Roles, rules and rolls
- Night's Dark Terror 15: Journey's End in Rifllian
- Night's Dark Terror 14: Funny Things Happen on the Way to the Horse Market
- New Dungeon Just Dropped! (Ancient School)
- Night's Dark Terror 13: Xitaqa 4, Curse You Golthar!
- Night's Dark Terror 12: Xitaqa 3, Up the Tower
- Night's Dark Terror 11: Xitaqa 2, Tower Base
- Night's Dark Terror 10: Xitaqa 1, Round the Houses
- Night's Dark Terror 9: Following the Clues
- Night's Dark Terror 8: Raid on the Goblin Fort
- Night's Dark Terror 7: Hexcrawling South of the River
Akratic
- It’s Tolkien Reading Day
- Darkmaster plans for 2024
- James M. Ward, RIP
- OSRIC Player's Guide
- Against the Witch-King: Chapter 1
- Against the Court of Urdor Campaign – Part 2
- My RPG Foci: Fantasy and Eldritch Horror
- Will Gygax’s Castle Greyhawk finally be published?
- Against the Court of Urdor Campaign – Part 1
- I Survived Helm's Deep
Lich house
- LOTFP Review: The Curious Conundrum of the Conflagrated Condottiero
- Catching Up with the Pillories (York 1630 Campaign)
- ACKS 2 Kickstarter - Last 24 Hours
- LOTFP Review: Winnie the Shit
- LOTFP Review: Galileo 2: Judgment Day
- LOTFP Review: Black Chamber
- Game Reports - ACKS and LOTFP
- The Strigoi - Vampire Alternative for LOTFP
- LOTFP Review: A Gift for All Norway
- Game Reports - York 1630 and ACKS Greyhawk
One of many southern French caves worth mentioning: the Grotte de Trabuc, namely because it was once a hideout for bandits preying on silk traders. A quintessential D&D dungeon!
That’s fantastic, thank you! Somehow I’ve never managed to get to the Ardeche.
There’s also some pretty nice sketch-mapping on their website: http://www.grotte-de-fontrabiouse.com/en/
….and I’m glad to discover your blog!